Does Anti-Israel Mean Anti-Semitic? An Answer From Liberal Logic

With the current violence in Israel continuing without a clear end in sight, Israel is once again receiving support and criticism for its policies. One common refrain found among Israel's supporters is that the inordinate amount of criticism levied against Israel is actually a form of anti-Semitism. When "anti-Israel" protesters reportedly shout "Kill the Jews" while looting Jewish businesses, it is easy to reach this conclusion. But aside from these violent outbreaks, is there any validity to the argument that the more civil rhetorical attacks against Israel are rooted in anti-Semitism? In her Remarks Before 2010 Conference on Combating Anti-Semitism, Special Envoy to Monitor and Combat Anti-Semitism Hannah Rosenthal offers criteria for distinction:

Our State Department uses Natan Sharansky’s framework for identifying when someone or a government crosses the line – when Israel is demonized, when Israel is held to different standards than the rest of the countries, and when Israel is delegitimized. These cases are not disagreements with a policy of Israel, this is anti-Semitism.[Emphasis added]

Writing for the New York Times in 2002, Thomas Friedman offered a similar contrast:

Criticizing Israel is not anti-Semitic, and saying so is vile. But singling out Israel for opprobrium and international sanction -- out of all proportion to any other party in the Middle East -- is anti-Semitic, and not saying so is dishonest.

There are no doubt other opinions and qualifications which answer this question, but I believe that for the Liberal Left - whose members tend to be some of Israel's most vocal and vitriolic critics - the definitions cited above are justifiable based on how it views discrimination in other contexts, particularly regarding the US criminal justice system.
Continue reading

Posted in Israel.

Ep. 162 The Farewell Class / A Shiur on Shimush

10448187_10203879921816460_5543220851218771374_nOn July 9th I delivered my final class at The Stanton St. Shul where I have been the rabbi for the past six years. Unfortunately, my attempts to record the video and audio both failed, so I re-recorded much of what was relevant in a preview of future "seasons" of podcasting. While I am disappointed that much of the emotion and personality from the original presentation may not have come though, part of me feels that it's only fitting to share full emotional range in the intimate setting comprised of the community which shared the very same experiences.

The purpose of this class was primarily to explain my approach towards leading the synagogue as its Rav, why and how I came to make some of the decisions I did, based on my own skills and capacity and the state of the shul as I saw it. At the very least I hope I can provide at least a partial sample of "behind the scenes" thinking and perhaps provide possibilities, solutions, or even just inspiration for those interested in leading or managing a religious community.

Ep. 162 The Farewell Class / A Shiur on Shimush

Posted in Podcasts.

Ep. 161 Laws of Shabbat 22 - Review and Conclusion

The exciting conclusion to Rabbi Yuter's class series on Maimonides' Laws of Shabbat.

Laws of Shabbat 22 - Review and Conclusion

Posted in Laws of Shabbat.

Ep. 160 Laws of Shabbat 21 - Chapter 30

Rabbi Yuter's Laws of Shabbat series discusses Chapter 30 of Rambam's Laws of Shabbat.

Laws of Shabbat 21 - Chapter 30

Posted in Laws of Shabbat.

Current Jewish Questions 1-50(ish) - The Stanton St. Shul Years

One of the great joys I've had in my time as the Rav of The Stanton St. Shul is the opportunity not just to teach Torah, but to do so in ways which may be more meaningful and relevant to people than they've previously encountered. The intent behind my Current Jewish Questions series was to start with real-world examples and explore some laws or ideas particular relevant to an actual situation. In this way, even obscure or difficult texts become accessible and relatable.

None of these classes were intended to be comprehensive - I'm constantly updating my own source sheets as I come across new material - but I hope they can serve as a useful introduction to many of the questions Jews encounter while living in the modern world, even if we cannot provide (or intentionally avoid) giving definitive answers.

Below is the complete list of all the Current Jewish Questions classes from my time at The Stanton St. Shul. 1 Please enjoy listening to the audio, following along with the source sheets, and feel free to adapt and modify these classes as you see fit for your own educational needs.
Continue reading

Notes:

  1. More classes were given though not all were uploaded for technical or quality reasons, hence the inconsistency in numbering. Either that or I simply can't count.
Posted in Current Jewish Questions.

Ep. 159 Current Jewish Questions 50 - Halakhic Humor

Rabbi Yuter closes out his Current Jewish Questions series at The Stanton Street Shul with a Very Special 50th class discussing parameters of humor in Rabbinic Judaism.

Current Jewish Questions - Halakhic Humor Sources (PDF)

Current Jewish Questions - Halakhic Humor

Posted in Current Jewish Questions.

Ep. 158 Current Jewish Questions 49 - Reparations for Slavery and Discrimination

Inspired by Ta-Nehisi Coates' recent Atlantic essay The Case for Reparations, Rabbi Yuter addresses this complicated topic through Biblical and Rabbinic sources.

Current Jewish Questions - Reparations Sources (PDF)

Current Jewish Questions - Reparations

Posted in Current Jewish Questions. Tagged with , , , , , , .

Ep. 157 Laws of Shabbat 20 - Carrying Conclusion

Rabbi Yuter's concludes the segment on carrying with a discussing of Rambam's Laws of Shabbat Chapter 19

Laws of Shabbat 20 - Carrying Conclusion

Posted in Laws of Shabbat.

Ep. 156 Current Jewish Questions 48 - Judaism and Evolution

In this class Rabbi Yuter addresses the theological challenge posed by evolution.

Current Jewish Questions - Evolution Sources (PDF)

Current Jewish Questions - Judaism and Evolution

Posted in Current Jewish Questions.

Ep. 155 Current Jewish Questions 47 - Science and Judaism

This class introduces the topic of how to handle when Judaism and science conflict with each other.

Current Jewish Questions - Science and Judaism Sources (PDF)

Current Jewish Questions - Science and Judaism

Posted in Current Jewish Questions.